Sci-Ence! Justice Leak!

A Personal Note on Functioning Labels

This is a far more personal post than I normally do here, and I apologise for that. I’ll be back to talking about old SF novels or something soon, I promise. I don’t feel comfortable at all talking about my personal life…

But I wanted to say something brief about functioning labels as they’re applied to autistic people, inspired by a thought I had today, and by a lot of talk recently about a particularly repellent example of the bad autism parent memoir. I wanted to explain why functioning labels for autistic people are far, far less use than they may appear.

By most of the standards that neurotypical people use, I am “high functioning”. Certainly I was able to remain in full-time employment consistently from 2004 through June last year without ever relying on any kind of benefits, and even after my massive breakdown and terrible health problems last year (from the stress of trying to do wage-work for so long in autism-hostile environments) I’m able more or less to earn enough to live on now through my writing (thanks largely to my Patreon backers), and the ability to function as a wage-earning unit is the only thing that really counts by any of the metrics used in current society.

This means that, in the eyes of “autism parents” (which I am using here as a technical term — I know many parents of autistic people who are entirely wonderful people, but I’m referring here to the people who, for example, write books about how they want to sterilise their son because he shouldn’t be allowed to breed), I am “high functioning”, and so I’m “not like my child” and utterly unable to have a sensible opinion about how autistic people should be treated.

But… I had a bit of a realisation today, while thinking about something unrelated — something I’d known as a fact about myself, but hadn’t really been aware of in a major way.

And that is that I am able, easily, to list all the in-person human contact I’ve had with anyone other than my wife in the last five weeks. Here it is, in total:

I have several times said “thanks” to a cashier in a shop.

My wife went out with friends for most of Sunday, and the friends came into our house for ten minutes.

I had three brief medical appointments, with a combined human-interaction time of approximately fifteen minutes.

That’s the lot. Every moment I’ve spent talking to another human being, other than my wife, in the same physical location since my trip to London in October.

There are several causes for this — my strange sleep schedule, my reduced mobility, and my dislike of loud, crowded, public places all play a part, as does my general introversion. All of these are part of my disability. But the biggest part is simply that I am completely, utterly, unable to navigate social interactions in even the most basic way.

There are a few social occasions I know how to navigate, but these are hyper-specific ones that don’t come up more than once or twice a year. Otherwise, it’s a good job I don’t have an especially strong desire to spend time with other people that often, because I wouldn’t have a clue how to go about it.

And this is disabling in ways that are extremely non-obvious. It’s certainly meant, throughout my life, that I have been far less effective at doing the things I’m passionate about than otherwise I would be. You build an audience as a writer through networking, and through building a client base — which I can’t do. I spent years wanting to be a musician, and think I have some real talent for songwriting and arranging. But as a non-singing composer, I’d have to rely on other people to sing my songs and play the other parts — but when I’ve been in bands, I’ve either been miserable myself or made other people miserable. And as a political campaigner, I have no hope ever of doing anything like getting selected as a Parliamentary candidate, even if I become well enough to do it, as I don’t have the ability to navigate the internal party structures necessary to build a support base in the party (much less the ability to then relate to the electorate in a way they can comprehend).

Similar things have happened in work situations (and contributed to my illness). Time and again I’ve worked harder than other people around me, and yet not worked on the right projects, or impressed the right people, because I have no instinct for these things.

This isn’t something as simple as “shyness” or “awkwardness”. And nor do I think it’s something that renders me especially unlikeable — plenty of people seem to like me if they’re forced into a position where they have to interact with me (I used to be an extremely good nursing assistant when I worked for a couple of years on a psychiatric ward, as the patients tended to like me and take me into their confidence more than they did most of the other staff). It’s a deeper cognitive thing. Most people seem to instinctively know their place in any social group, like there’s a hierarchy there which they can fit into almost straight away. I, on the other hand, am completely unable to even conceptualise social interactions in those terms, which leads to people either thinking I’m being horribly rude and or thinking that I’m standoffish because whatever signals I send out seem to get interpreted either as “I should be in charge” or “bother me not with your petty concerns, mortals”, or something.

Now, this sounds like nothing at all serious, when I try to explain it. But this is a *profound* inability to function. It’s an inability to develop the kind of network of friendships and casual acquaintanceships that other people have (which makes the few friends I do have all the more valuable to me, incidentally — “not many” is very different from “none at all”), and in an economic system where advancement and security are functions not of ability to do productive work but of ability to be a “team player” and to make a good impression on one’s boss, it’s *hideously* disabling.

And yet this is something that would never be taken into account in most discussions of how “well-functioning” an autistic person is. Because in limited situations I can pass as neurotypical, at great cognitive expense, for a short time, and because I’m verbal, I must not be disabled.

Yet if you’re a neurotypical person reading this, think what you would consider “not much time spent around other people”. Think how you’d cope if there were months when you spent twenty-five minutes, total, in the company of someone other than your partner.

How well would you really think you were functioning then?

This blog post has been brought to you by the generosity of my backers on Patreon. Why not join them?